Comments from Monica Martin

Comments from Monica Martin. These comments are referencing the HTML Query QA UBL Naming Definitions.html document.

Original comments from Monica, in black.
Suggestions and comments in Red from Lisa Seaburg, 1 July 2002.

BIE	Question	Comments or Suggestion (if applicable)
Ship ToLocation UBL000295 and UBL000296	No-space names	To allow for processing and lower chance of errors FIX: fix spreadsheet to take out spaces???
CurrencyIdentificationCode UBL000133	May not be at header level – account. Could be transactional or by release of a purchase order for example	Consider lower level association
TypeCode UBL000168 Contract type code UBL000222 (Tax) type code UBL000145 Reference type code UBL000070 Size type code UBL000139 Type ID	There are many type codes besides contract	Revise to generic TypeCode or multiple types of "TypeCode" This needs to be looked at. But I think each type is unique, we could maybe model it differently to be more neutral and reuseable.
CurrencyCode UBL000133 CurrencyIdentificationCode UBL000179 UBL000180	Need for to and from currency to accommodate the transitions of the transaction itself (particularly for accounting – audit mechanism – as may infer agreement/contractual responsibility)	ToCurrencyCode FromCurrencyCode Doesn’t ExchangeRateDetails take care of this? Yes, it could although this brings up two items: The currency for the account (like a default) – not sure if to or from – and the transaction where UBL000179 and 180 accommodate.
SizeTypeCode UBL000070 See comments above	How to handle aggregated or embedded types Size and type	Suggest a type of "TypeCode" and a SizeCode that are aggregated to SizeTypeCode if desired by the business context
CreditCard UBL000123 is CardInfo UBL000150 – 156	Duplicates with 123 and 150 – two credit cards entities	Delete duplicate. I think CardInfo should be inside of Card Details.
PriceQuantityRange to Quantity UBL000098	How to decompose these aggregates?	Quantity Price PriceQuantityPrice Many types of Quantity As it is, this should show depth of elements, PriceQuantityRange has two elements or attributes (?) Show these better. MinimumValue and MaximumValue.